College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students Jobs and internships for students -

Confederate flag no more honorable than swastika

Contributing Writer

Published: Tuesday, December 1, 2009

Updated: Tuesday, December 1, 2009 14:12

You see it on bumper stickers. You see it on T-shirts. You even see it waving over some state capitals.

Yep, you guessed it: the Confederate flag, otherwise known as the rebel flag.

While some consider it a symbol of racism and bigotry, others contend that the Confederate flag is a symbol of southern culture and heritage.

But whose heritage? The rebel flag that we see now never historically represented the Confederate States of America as a nation. And let’s be real: The Civil War was about slavery.

People will say, “No, the war was about state’s rights.”

Yeah, state’s rights to own slaves!

South Carolina planter and state Senator John Townsend said, “Our enemies are about to take possession of the government, that they intend to rule us…according to the declared purposes of abolishing slavery.”

Yes, there were other minor ingredients involved in southern secession, but slavery was the meat of the corned beef sandwich from hell that was the American Civil War.

There is a southern culture that should be celebrated — like hospitality, college football, cornbread and chicken. Not racism.

Though proponents of the flag claim it has no political or racial connotations, they really don’t seem too eager to stop hate groups like the Ku Klux Klan or the Aryan Nation from waving the rebel flag proudly.

I’m sure that the Jewish citizens of Germany would not like to see Nazi flags being waved across the country.

In fact Interior Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble has stated Germany’s official policy is not to “tolerate any form of…anti-Semitism.”

It’s a criminal offense! Ah, aren’t you glad that we have freedom of speech in this country?

Now there is nothing wrong with showing regional pride. I’m very proud of my southern roots.

Yet images such as the Confederate flag remind most Americans of a country divided. Take the Battle of Okinawa during WWII.

After the battle, a Marine from the self-proclaimed “Rebel Company” raised a Confederate flag over one of the castles.

After three days, Gen. Simon B. Buckner, Jr., son of Confederate Gen. Simon B. Buckner, gave orders for the flag to be taken down, stating that it was inappropriate because “Americans from all over are involved in this battle.”

Not to mention, why wave a flag of the nation that lost and ultimately no longer exists?

Those Confederate images caused problems here locally. From 1972 to 1977 Escambia High School was riddled with race riots after the all-white school was forced to desegregate.

Blacks and other students protested the racially over-toned school song “Dixie,” the Col. Reb school mascot and the use of the Confederate flag during school events.

In 1973, the federal courts ruled the images were “racially insensitive.” After more violence ensued, students eventually voted to have “Gators” become the school mascot. Go Gators!

Still, I know that as long there is Hank Williams, Jr., Lynyrd Skynyrd, and the great state of Mississippi, the Confederate flag isn’t going anywhere anytime soon.

Though I miss those days after September 2001 when all you saw on bumper stickers and T-Shirts were flags of the United States of America.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

31 comments

Jackson
Wed Dec 2 2009 19:56
Maybe the writer should read Lincoln's Inaugural address:

"I have no purpose, directly or indirectly, to interfere with the institution of slavery in the States where it exists. I believe I have no lawful right to do so, and I have no inclination to do so."

KentuckyThunder
Wed Dec 2 2009 18:48
this is the sorriest excuse for an article i've ever had the misfortune of reading, how ignorant and ill informed can one poor wretch be? i fly my Confederate flag on my truck and on my porch, i have no problem with any black person who respects my culture, people think they are fighting a war agianst ignorance and bigotry, when the fact is they are the ignorant ones and are a bigot toward southerners, your federal gov't textbooks may say the "civil war" was about slavery, but i got news for you, history is written by the winner, true or false. and it wasn't a civil war, a civil war is a war between two factions seeking control over a single gov't and we southerners wanted no control over your tyrannical gov't, we wanted a gov't of our own and for us and to be a seperate nation, we are a different people from the northerners. And the United States hasn't existed since 1865, there is no such thing as forced unity or a forced union. using force or an army to force a political union is exactly the same thing Hitler did with Austria, so who is behaving like Nazis here? Southerners? or the U.S Federal Government? please get a clue and be a little better informed next time you take a stab at us, instead of playing the typical racist card, because quite frankly, that crap is getting old.
William
Wed Dec 2 2009 18:35
Ever notice that sometimes those who preach "tolerance" are often actually very intolerant of viewpoints other than theirs?
True Confederate
Wed Dec 2 2009 18:28
As for comparing the Confederate Battle flag to the Swastika !
The Nazi’s were trying to rule the world . The Confederates were fighting for independence against an invading army.!
If you need to compare The Nazi cause with a movement /

Try Abe Lincoln. Just as hitler was for the extermination of Jews

Lincoln was for the deportation of blacks from American soil !

Mr Lincoln Stated
“ The enterprise is a difficult one, but 'when there is a will there is a way;' and what colonization needs most is a hearty will. Will springs from the two elements of moral sense and self-interest. Let us be brought to believe it is morally right, and, at the same time, favorable to, or, at least, not against, our interest, to transfer the African to his native clime, and we shall find a way to do it, however great the task may be.”

Mac
Wed Dec 2 2009 16:40
Others have already commented, so I'll keep it brief.

This article screams, "I'm an ignorant idiot." Period. Go to the library and do some real research next time.

Jamey
Wed Dec 2 2009 13:29
How accurate can this guy be? He claims there are still Confederate flags flying over capitol buildings? Well in case he missed it there are not.
Roy
Wed Dec 2 2009 09:42
This article is terribly uninformed. Please remember that after any war, the history books are always written by the victors. The war was bigger than just slavery, and the Confederate flag is bigger than just the war. So, you are making a huge leap in logic to assume that the flag is all about hatred. I can't even believe I took the time to respond to this.
topcat
Wed Dec 2 2009 09:32
"Freedom Whiting...
Major: Pre-Law
Minor: History"

Very Minor. Typical PC indoctrination clap-trap.

Mississippian
Wed Dec 2 2009 06:49
The federal courts also ruled the Confederate a historic US flag and gave soldiers who fought under it VA privileges. The US flag is where slavery originated and northern ports is where they were brought in. We are not the Confederate States anymore but we are the most patriotic areas in the country and have always been. Since we dont call our selves the Confedertae States, whats up with northern states calling themselves "The New England States"? I guess they dont want to be part of the good old United States of America. Are they racially charged?
Paul Christopher
Tue Dec 1 2009 21:19
You are a fool. Believing that the Southern Solder went to die to preserve slavery is almost as naive as believing the North invaded the South to free them.
Wayne Scarborough
Tue Dec 1 2009 19:45
Freedom Whiting, is that a real name? You claim to have Southern Roots, but yet you compare Honorable Southern Men to the swastika. You babble on about something you read somewhere and post these types of comments. You haven't even scrapped the surface of resent History. Until you do, don't insult Us with your immature remarks.






log out